Friday, November 20, 2026

A '.edu' Biotherapeutic Drainage Round-Up - 2026

here, some first-page hits and a broad critical preponderance:

001. via the prompt to Google's web search, >site:.edu "biotherapeutic drainage" naturopathic<, the following results occur:

001.a. a American College of Healthcare Sciences page which states he's an NUNM graduate and "in addition to holding an ND, he has trained extensively in biotherapeutic drainage with Seroyal / UNDA, which has influenced his ability to work across various traditions of care";

001.b. the NUNM alumni practice page "Sparrow Medicine" which indicates use of the practice;

001.c. the CCNM pdf "Mind, Body, Spirit" which is a winter 2013 publication containing an ad for biotherapeutic drainage;

001.d. an NUNM 2016 dated page "Celebrating Faculty Excellence" which speaks of "a six–month internship focusing on chronic disease management and biotherapeutic drainage";

002. via Google's Gemini and the question "has anything ever been measured to have 'drained'?":

"No. There is zero empirical evidence that any toxin, metabolic waste, or 'homotoxin' has ever been measurably 'drained' from the body by biotherapeutic drainage remedies. In fact, the premise fails at the most basic level of chemistry and physiology:

The Remedies Contain No Active Molecules.

Biotherapeutic drainage typically relies on UNDA numbered compounds (or similar drainage formulas made by brands like Heel, Pekana, or DesBio). These are low-potency homeopathic preparations, usually diluted to 4X, 6X, 12X, or 30X (decimal dilutions) or 4C to 30C (centesimal dilutions). Because of Avogadro's limit, dilutions beyond 24X or 12C contain statistically zero molecules of the original plant, mineral, or animal tissue. Even at lower dilutions (e.g., 4X or 6X), the concentrations are trace parts-per-million or parts-per-billion—far below any threshold capable of inducing a pharmacological, enzymatic, or physiological change in hepatic (liver) or renal (kidney) clearance pathways.

No Defined 'Toxin' to Measure.

Proponents of biotherapeutic drainage use vague, pre-scientific terminology rather than identifiable chemical compounds: Instead of naming specific, measurable molecules (like lead, bilirubin, creatinine, or specific persistent organic pollutants), practitioners refer to undefined 'toxins,' 'miasms,' 'energetic blockages,' or 'homotoxins' (a term coined by Hans-Heinrich Reckeweg in the 1950s). Because these targets are non-physical or deliberately undefined, they cannot be quantified via blood panels, urinalysis, mass spectrometry, or fecal assays before and after treatment.

Lack of Clinical or Excretory Studies.

To demonstrate that a substance 'drains' toxins, a study would need to show an increase in the excretion rate of specific, verified toxins in urine, bile, stool, or sweat compared to a placebo control, alongside a corresponding drop in tissue or serum levels. No peer-reviewed, randomized controlled trials have ever demonstrated increased clearance of any heavy metal, environmental pollutant, or endogenous metabolic waste product following the administration of UNDA numbers or drainage remedies. When proponents claim 'drainage is working,' they typically point to subjective, non-specific symptoms—such as headaches, fatigue, loose stools, skin breakouts, or changes in mood—and reinterpret them as a 'healing crisis' or 'Herxheimer reaction.' In reality, these are either natural symptom fluctuations, the nocebo effect, or mild gastrointestinal reactions to the alcohol/glycerin base used in liquid homeopathic drops.

Misrepresentation of Normal Physiology.

Biotherapeutic drainage relies on the vitalistic assumption that the body's 'emunctories' (organs of elimination like the liver, kidneys, skin, lungs, and colon) become congested with stored toxins and require 'energetic' nudging to open up. In human physiology, hepatic biotransformation (Phase I and Phase II liver enzymes) and glomerular filtration in the kidneys operate continuously based on concentration gradients, blood flow, and enzymatic capacity—not homeopathic signaling."

003. incidentally, in the 2026 CT ND Final Report, the root >biotherap< occurs ZERO times.  While, in the raw data file, it occurs TEN times.

Thursday, November 19, 2026

My 2026 Successful Borrower Defense to Repayment Case: $190,000 Scrubbed for Institutional Misconduct (ISYN!).

here, I’ll share great news of an incremental win in terms of my ‘naturopathy educational exploitation’ while acknowledging that the fight is perpetual and larger than just my case, my experience, and merely loans:

[2026-09-26. Note: I am not whole, I’ll emphasize – as in my quarter-century-plus career hole created by the AANP-AANMC-CNME-CAND-NABNE-CNPA etc. induced diversion / falsehood].

001. my student loan aggregate has been largely annulled!!!:

after decades of carrying a very large amount of student loans due to graduate school — a poor boy trying to get forward since the mid-1990s; like being at the bottom of an empty, 1-mile deep well eventually — I owe a lot less money in light of the Department of Education’s acceptance of my borrow defense to repayment argument this 2026.

presently, I do not know the details of their thinking as such hasn’t been communicated -- what is still outstanding is part of a program I attended that had loans discharged.

at its largest, the education debt looked like this or so in 2025 while in good standing [about $190,000]:

 

 and I’d always say it was like having a mortgage but without the house to show for it.

as in debt slavery. 

yes, quite remarkable!

indeed miraculous -- to now be a partial school misconduct survivor.

as the .gov site states [I'll paraphrase]:

institutional misconduct is a definitive, foundational trait of an approved borrower defense to repayment discharge.

Sunday, November 15, 2026

The Naturocrit Podcast - Episode 015d [s02e05d] - Script & Annotations

here, the final part of Episode 015, as Part D, wherein I process the material that was generated from Episode 015's Part C through the Cullen Snyder Framework v1.2 with help from the 2026 CT ND Final Report.  First, presentation of v1.2, then, of the study's concluding output which is titled "Macro-to-Micro Synthesis of Naturopathic Institutional Architecture and Clinical Practice: A Cullen-Snyder Framework (v1.2) Evaluation of World Naturopathic Federation Doctrine and Connecticut Licensure (Chapter 373 / PA 14-231)."

[and I'll do this with standard left margin text alignment!]:

Standard Introduction

Welcome to, as that robot voice says, The Naturocrit Podcast, and thank you for boldly listening.

What ARE we even talking about?

Well, this podcast series is my take on naturopathic medicine, an area I've been studying for about thirty-four years, including my time in so-called 'scientific nonsectarian naturopathic medical school'.

My approach is a pairing of scientific skepticism and a deep knowledge of naturopathy's intimate details.

In previous episodes of this series, I established that naturopathy is, essentially, a kind of knowledge blending, misrepresentation, and irrationality.

I have termed naturopathy both 'an epistemic conflation falsely posing itself as an epistemic delineation' and 'the naturopathillogical':

the science-exterior is mixed with what is scientific, then that whole muddle is absurdly claimed to be science as an entire category, while particular sectarian science-ejected oath-obligations and -requirements are coded or camouflaged, therein effectively disguising naturopathy's system of beliefs in public view.

Naturopathy's ultimate achievement is a profound erosion of scientific integrity and freedom of belief packaged in the marketing veneers "natural, holistic, integrative and alternative" and improperly embedded in the academic category "science."

Synopsis

In this Naturocrit Podcast Episode 015 Part D, also known as Season 02 Episode 5d, titled “Unfinished Episode 015 Business”, I will return to and complete the informal study I had re-titled “A Qualitative Content Analysis of Curated World Naturopathic Federation Publications and Reports Employing the Online Misinformation Engagement Framework Within a Paradigm of Methodological Naturalism.”

This is occurring after having published Episodes 016 and 017, chronologically speaking for those who are counting, which yes, is a little odd.

The gap in terms of the calendar is about a year and a half.

But, the object of my analyses all these years, naturopathy, is quite odd too...

So, no worries.

The previous Episode 015 parts that immediately pertain to the study —  C1, C2, C3 — were achieved through QualCoder manually, resulting in, in terms of the O’Brien et al. 2014 model that was employed, Step 1 through Step 16 which encompass the model study areas of Title and Abstract, Introduction, Methods, and Results / Findings.

So, herein, I’ll communicate Steps 17 and onward which in the O’Brien model are Links to Empirical Findings and Discussion.

Contextually, the technique gap or difference between Episode 015 previous to this concluding part D and what I’m now sharing is best noted by my implementation and adoption of what I’m calling ai-llm upon naturopathy materials — as opposed to the manual — as seen in Episode 016 and 17 with the creation and application of the Cullen-Snyder Framework.

And this Episode 015 study will be completed through prompts and interrogations presented to Google’s Gemini 4 Argon ai-llm model circa this final quarter of 2026.

The Naturocrit Podcast - Episode 015d [s02e05d] MP3 Link

In this multi-part Naturocrit Podcast Episode 015, aka s02e05, retitled from “The JACM 2019 Special Issue on Naturopathy” to “A Qualitative Content Analysis of Curated World Naturopathic Federation Publications and Reports Employing the Online Misinformation Engagement Framework Within a Paradigm of Methodological Naturalism,” I'll be sharing a study I've recently written in a semi-scholarly manner.

---

This is the fourth and final part of Episode 015, Part D, wherein I process the material that was generated from Episode 015's Part C study/project through the Cullen Snyder Framework v1.2 with help from the 2026 CT ND Final Report.  First, presentation of v1.2, then of the study's concluding output which is titled "Macro-to-Micro Synthesis of Naturopathic Institutional Architecture and Clinical Practice: A Cullen-Snyder Framework (v1.2) Evaluation of World Naturopathic Federation Doctrine and Connecticut Licensure (Chapter 373 / PA 14-231)."

.

.

or

.

.

Friday, November 13, 2026

The Cullen-Snyder Framework (v.1.1) Application #012 – The Colorado AND's Neuropathies CME

here, via Google's Gemini Argon model of 2026-11, I apply the CSF v1.1 to a video up at vimeo.com. First, I set the tone in 001., wherein a logical inconsistency at the heart of naturopathy is highlighted. Then, in 002., there's the video and the report on the video in light of the 2026 CT Final Report:

001. at the Colorado Association of Naturopathic Doctors' coloradond.org, we're told in "What Is Naturopathic Medicine?" [archived here]:

001.a. about the core commitment of naturopathy, vitalism: 

“naturopathic doctors use the Therapeutic Order to prioritize, individualize, and guide treatment [...] the following are the seven components and stages of the therapeutic order [...#2] stimulate the body’s self-healing mechanisms. Every person has within them an innate wisdom and intelligence that tends toward the optimal expression of health. In naturopathic medicine, this is called the ‘vis medicatrix naturae.’ The ‘vis medicatrix naturae’ is the body’s innate healing ability, the process of healing which engages with one’s ‘vital force’ or life force, as it is often termed. Naturopathic physicians use various therapies such as nutrition, botanical medicine, physical medicine, lifestyle counseling, acupuncture, homeopathy and hydrotherapy to stimulate and enhance this mighty and dynamic force and process allowing the body to heal itself [...]";

so, explicit vitalism at the core of naturopathy's activities.

"what are the principles of naturopathic medicine? The practice of naturopathic medicine is rooted in the following six guiding principles [...#2] the healing power of nature (vis medicatrix naturae). Naturopathic medicine acknowledges an inherent, ordered and intelligent healing process in all living organisms. Naturopathic doctors identify and remove obstacles to cure to facilitate this healing ability in patients [...]";

and so, there you have that very-same vitalism in a different section of the page, coded.  The TO section serves as a kind of Rosetta Stone towards understanding what is actually being expressed in the coded section.

001.b. naturopathy's supposed simultaneous science footprint:

Tuesday, November 10, 2026

Featuring “On Freedom”: 2026 Tim Snyder “Now We Act” Videos with Legislators

here, I list the interviews that Tim Snyder did with lawmakers post-midterm elections 2026.  The connection to the Naturocrit blog is acknowledgment and thanks regarding the Snyder portion of the Cullen-Snyder Framework v1.1 and v1.2:

[I’ll emphasized that Snyder is not a active contributor to the CSF, but I based the positive freedom aspects of the CSF on Snyder’s book “On Freedom” which is seen behind Snyder in many of these videos; I’ll be adding to this list as the days progress if necessary]

001. the many videos at YouTube [regardless of party affiliation]:

"Now We Act (Ep. 1 with Rep. Seth Magaziner)”;

"Now We Act (with Sen. Maggie Hassan)";

“Now We Act (with Rep. Greg Casar)";

"Now We Act (with Rep. Ro Khanna)";

"Now We Act (with Sen. Tina Smith)";

"Now We Act (with Rep. Madeleine Dean)";

"Now We Act (with Sen. Mark Kelly)";

"Now We Act (with Sen. Chris Van Hollen)";

"Now We Act (with Sen. Richard Blumenthal)";

"Now We Act (with Sen. Andy Kim)";

Sunday, November 8, 2026

A Gemini Round-Up of North American Naturopathy’s Woes & 'the Broad Deceit' - 2026-11

here, I point Google's Gemini ai-llm at naturopathy in terms of naturopathy's 2026 accreditation woes and what I know to be its decades-longstanding epistemic spoliation / transgression / deceit:

001.a. Gemini prompt:

“Are there any publicly published defenses that have come out this year regarding naturopathy schools in North America and their accreditor / USDE troubles?”

001.b. answer:

“In 2026, the naturopathic academic and professional establishment issued multiple coordinated public statements, formal comments, and organizational filings in defense of their accreditor, the Council on Naturopathic Medical Education (CNME).

These defenses were triggered by the National Advisory Committee on Institutional Quality and Integrity (NACIQI) voting in March 2026 to recommend that the U.S. Department of Education (USDE) deny renewal of federal recognition to CNME, followed by the Senior Department Official's (SDO) June 2026 decision to grant a conditional 12-month limited recognition reprieve.

The primary public defenses and rhetorical frameworks advanced this year fall into four main categories:

1. AANMC & AANP Joint Damage Control Statement (March 25, 2026). Immediately following NACIQI’s vote recommending denial of re-recognition, the Association of Accredited Naturopathic Medical Colleges (AANMC) and the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians (AANP) issued a joint statement to students, faculty, and practitioners. Key arguments in this defense included: